Is “Mankind” caged in the British Museum?
31 / 12 / 2008
The Parthenon Marbles were fixtures that were attached to buildings on the Parthenon for more than 2,300 years until they were forcibly removed by Lord Elgin’s agents.
Sir, The suggestion by Professor Buranelli that the Parthenon Marbles “belong to mankind” is aspirational (“Call to unite Parthenon Marbles”, Dec 4); that they “lay forgotten on the ground” until Lord Elgin appropriated them is untrue.
The Parthenon Marbles were fixtures that were attached to buildings on the Parthenon for more than 2,300 years until they were forcibly removed by Lord Elgin’s agents. As such, they belong to the buildings to which they were attached, unless it can be indisputably demonstrated that their removal was expressly agreed to by the owners of the buildings. Ownership to them could only be transferred on the strongest evidence that a right to remove them had been granted. That would normally require the sort of documentary evidence that does not seem to exist. What little evidence there is, as the professor admits, suggests that Lord Elgin “interpreted in his own favour” — something that a court of law or, indeed, any sensible lawyer might question.
Regardless of whether this constitutes a “juridical” basis for disputing Lord Elgin’s, and therefore the British Museum’s title to the Marbles, it seems a flimsy foundation on which to construct a “European museum”.
John Kapranos Huntley
Professor of Law (ret’d)
Bearsden, East Dunbartonshire
Source: Is “Mankind” caged in the British Museum?
31 / 12 / 2008 | Tags: Europe, For England James, Parthenon Sculptures, RETURN THE PARTHENON SCULPTURES |
An independent movement of free thinkers sharing the same dream: a better world inspired by the Hellenic ideals that gave birth to civilizations: Freedom, Direct Democracy, Humanism, Reason, Justice, and the Pursuit of Excellence.
